Vermont Portrait of a Graduate: Six Attributes and the Proficiency Question

The Vermont Portrait of a Graduate names six attributes: learner agency, global citizenship, academic proficiency, communication, critical thinking and problem solving, and well-being.
Portrait of a Graduate
October 15, 2026
5 Min

The Vermont Portrait of a Graduate names six attributes: learner agency, global citizenship, academic proficiency, communication, critical thinking and problem solving, and well-being. The Vermont Agency of Education developed it from 2017 with more than three hundred students, educators and community members, and each attribute carries published performance indicators.

What Is the Vermont Portrait of a Graduate?

The Vermont Portrait of a Graduate is a statewide framework specifying the cognitive, personal and interpersonal skills and knowledge that Vermont students should be able to demonstrate on graduation. The Vermont Agency of Education publishes it as a tool for reviewing and refining local graduation requirements and for guiding instructional decisions.

Vermont is unusual in what the Portrait is attached to. Rather than sitting alongside the graduation system as a statement of values, it clarifies the College and Career Readiness expectations set out in Vermont’s Education Quality Standards, which require that graduation requirements rest on demonstrations of proficiency rather than time spent in classrooms. That requirement took effect with the graduating class of 2020. For how other states have positioned their frameworks, see what a Portrait of a Graduate is.

The Agency sets out how the Portrait relates to graduation in its Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements guidance.

The consequence is that Vermont went further than any other state in this comparison. Most states publish a portrait and hope it influences practice. Vermont built a graduation system around proficiency and used the Portrait to define what that proficiency should add up to.

What Are the Six Vermont Portrait of a Graduate Attributes?

The Vermont Portrait of a Graduate names six attributes, each with key descriptors and performance indicators published by the Agency of Education.

‍

Attribute What it covers
Learner agency The student’s capacity to direct their own learning, set goals and act on them. Vermont is the only state in this comparison to name agency as an attribute in its own right
Global citizenship Engagement with diverse perspectives and contribution to community and wider society
Academic proficiency Demonstrated proficiency against Vermont’s content standards, held inside the Portrait rather than separate from it
Communication Expressing and exchanging ideas across audiences, settings and media
Critical thinking and problem solving Analyzing information, evaluating evidence and reaching defensible solutions
Well-being Physical, social and emotional health as a condition of learning rather than an adjacent concern

‍

Learner agency deserves explanation because the term is not widely used elsewhere and is easily misread as student choice. In Vermont it describes the student acting as the driver of their own learning: setting direction, monitoring progress and adjusting. Placing it first among the six is a statement about what the whole framework is for.

Vermont also applies the Portrait inside individual subjects rather than only across them. The Agency of Education publishes content-area versions, including A Vermont Portrait of a Graduate through World Language and an Arts Proficiency-Based Graduation Hierarchy, each mapping the six attributes onto the terms of that discipline. No other state in this comparison does that, and it is the clearest evidence that Vermont intended the Portrait to reach classroom planning rather than stay at system level.

How Does the Vermont Portrait of a Graduate Connect to Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements?

Vermont’s Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements are the locally defined set of content knowledge and skills, connected to state standards, that qualify a student for a diploma. The Portrait of a Graduate defines what those requirements should collectively produce, and is used as a tool for reviewing and refining them.

The assessment architecture runs in four layers, and using Vermont’s own terms matters when reading its documents.

  • Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements. One per content area, expressing what it means to be literate within that discipline.
  • Critical Proficiencies. The proficiencies that support teaching and learning toward each requirement.
  • Priority Performance Indicators. Developed for each Critical Proficiency, and the only layer formally assessed to develop evidence of student proficiency.
  • Proficiency Scales. The progression of learning over time.

The point worth carrying away is that only the Priority Performance Indicators are formally assessed. All standards remain in the curriculum, but the evidence of proficiency is gathered against a defined subset. That is a deliberate narrowing, and it is the mechanism that made proficiency-based graduation administrable at all.

The narrowing has a second effect districts should plan for. Because the assessed layer is a subset, a school can satisfy its graduation requirements while evidencing only part of what the Portrait describes. Well-being and learner agency in particular tend to sit outside the formally assessed indicators, which means a district that wants to show progress against all six attributes has to collect evidence beyond what the graduation system strictly requires.

Is the Vermont Portrait of a Graduate Mandatory?

The Portrait itself is a tool rather than a mandate. What is binding in Vermont is the Education Quality Standards requirement that graduation requirements rest on demonstrations of proficiency, which has applied since the class of 2020.

That distinction explains a common confusion. A Vermont district is not required to adopt the six attributes, but it is required to run proficiency-based graduation requirements, and the Agency of Education offers the Portrait as the means of making those requirements coherent. In practice the two are difficult to separate.

The Agency also publishes resources for schools that want to refine the Portrait to reflect local context, including protocols for engaging students, educators and community members and materials for analyzing the feedback. Local adaptation is expected rather than discouraged.

What Does the Vermont Agency of Education Publish?

The core document is A Vermont Portrait of a Graduate with Performance Indicators, published in April 2020. It sets out the six attributes with their key descriptors and the performance indicators attached to each.

The document is published as A Vermont Portrait of a Graduate with Performance Indicators.

Alongside it the Agency publishes the content-area portraits, the proficiency-based graduation hierarchies that connect requirements to critical proficiencies and priority performance indicators, and community engagement resources for local refinement. The work was developed in collaboration with the Great Schools Partnership.

Vermont publishes performance indicators rather than rubrics, and the difference is more than terminological. Indicators describe what is assessed; rubrics describe levels of quality within it. Districts building the second layer from Vermont’s first will find transferable structure in Portrait of a Graduate rubric examples, since the criteria pattern carries across frameworks even where the attribute names differ.

‍

Proficiency Has to Be Demonstrated Somewhere

Vermont built a graduation system on demonstrations rather than seat time, which puts the weight on student work and where it is kept. Wakelet holds artifacts, drafts and recorded presentations in collections that follow a student across grades and teachers.

‍

The Agency additionally maintains quality criteria documents used to review proficiency-based graduation requirements and their related critical proficiencies and priority performance indicators, and has run practitioner feedback sessions on revisions. For a district auditing its own requirements against the Portrait, those review criteria are the most directly usable Vermont resource and the one most often overlooked.

How Did Vermont Develop Its Portrait of a Graduate?

The Vermont Agency of Education began developing a statewide Portrait of a Graduate with the field in 2017, seeking a shared vision for proficiency-based learning and for college and career readiness. Around sixty educators gathered to respond to the first draft.

The final version was developed collaboratively by more than three hundred Vermont students, community members and educators. That number is worth citing when the question of legitimacy arises, because it is a substantial proportion of the professional community in a state of Vermont’s size, and it is why the Portrait is treated locally as a shared document rather than an Agency product.

Vermont began this work earlier than most. Development starting in 2017 places it ahead of North Carolina and Kentucky in 2022 and New York in 2025, and means Vermont has had a longer run of implementation experience than almost any other state, including experience of what has not worked.

What Changed for Vermont Graduation Requirements in 2026?

In February 2026 the Vermont Agency of Education put recommendations to the House Education committee proposing a move toward credit-based graduation requirements, at 22.5 total credits, rather than continuing to rely on locally determined proficiency-based requirements.

The trigger was a United States Department of Education monitoring visit in 2024, which found uneven rigor across Vermont’s flexible pathways and graduation requirements. Federal law requires that each pathway to a regular high school diploma be aligned with the requirements for the standard diploma most students follow, and a pathway that is clearly less rigorous does not meet that test.

The Agency’s reasoning on the change is worth reading carefully rather than paraphrasing loosely. Its position is that alternative units of measure such as proficiencies carry a broader range of understood definitions across the state than credit does, which makes consensus on a common definition harder. The recommendation of 22.5 credits is presented as supporting flexible pathways under Act 77 while allowing room for career and technical education and for students who need additional time.

Two things this is not. It is not an abandonment of the Portrait of a Graduate, which the recommendations retain as the thing graduation requirements should align to. And it is not a verdict that proficiency-based learning failed. It is a judgment about whether proficiency is a workable unit of account for a diploma across an entire state.

For districts in other states, it is the most useful cautionary case available anywhere, because Vermont pushed furthest and is the first to report back. The lesson is not that proficiency-based graduation is wrong, but that a shared definition of what counts as proficient has to exist before the system depends on it. Check the current legislative position before relying on this, since the recommendations were still before the legislature at the time of writing.

How Do Vermont Districts Evidence the Attributes?

Vermont districts evidence the attributes through the Priority Performance Indicators attached to each Critical Proficiency, which are the layer formally assessed. Evidence is gathered from student work rather than from a single terminal assessment.

Learner agency and well-being are the hardest of the six and illustrate why. Neither is visible in a finished assignment. Agency shows up in the choices a student makes across a project and in how they respond when something fails, which means it has to be captured while the work is happening. Well-being is not a performance at all.

Vermont’s content-area portraits help here, because they translate the attributes into subject terms a teacher can act on. What they do not solve is where the resulting evidence lives across four years and several teachers, which is the collection problem set out in building student portfolios from K to 12.

The 2026 recommendations make this more pressing rather than less. If the unit of account moves back toward credits, the Portrait becomes the thing that gives those credits meaning, and demonstrating that meaning depends entirely on student work a district can still produce.

There is also a practical sequencing point specific to Vermont. Because proficiency-based requirements are set locally, two neighboring Vermont districts can define proficiency differently for the same attribute, which is precisely the unevenness the federal monitoring visit identified. Districts reviewing their requirements now would be well served by comparing definitions with peers before the state settles on a common unit, rather than after.

How Does Vermont Compare with Other State Portraits?

Vermont is the most deeply integrated of the state portraits and the one with the longest implementation record.

‍

State Started Attributes Integration with graduation
Vermont 2017 Six, with performance indicators Tied to proficiency-based graduation requirements from the class of 2020. Recommendations to move toward 22.5 credits, February 2026
Utah May 2019 13 characteristics None. Explicitly aspirational
North Carolina October 2022 Seven durable skills None. Voluntary framework with a full rubric package
Kentucky October 2022 Six competencies Voluntary, with local accountability redesign underway
New York July 2025 Six attributes Statewide alignment required from the 2029 cohort

‍

The comparison with New York is the instructive one. New York is moving toward a competency-based diploma and has set a cohort date; Vermont has been running the closest equivalent for six years and is now recommending a partial step back. Any state following New York’s path should read Vermont’s experience first. See the New York State Portrait of a Graduate implementation guide for that timeline, or the North Carolina Portrait of a Graduate for the lower-risk voluntary model.

Vermont Portrait of a Graduate FAQs

What Are the Six Vermont Portrait of a Graduate Attributes?

The six attributes are learner agency, global citizenship, academic proficiency, communication, critical thinking and problem solving, and well-being. Each carries key descriptors and performance indicators published by the Vermont Agency of Education.

What Are Vermont Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements?

Proficiency-Based Graduation Requirements are the locally defined content knowledge and skills, connected to state standards, that qualify a Vermont student for a high school diploma. Vermont’s Education Quality Standards required graduation to rest on demonstrated proficiency rather than classroom time from the graduating class of 2020.

Is Vermont Ending Proficiency-Based Graduation?

Not as such. In February 2026 the Agency of Education recommended moving toward 22.5 credit-based graduation requirements, following a 2024 federal monitoring finding of uneven rigor across flexible pathways. The Portrait of a Graduate remains the framework those requirements are meant to align to. Check the current legislative status.

Who Developed the Vermont Portrait of a Graduate?

The Vermont Agency of Education began the work in 2017 in collaboration with the field and the Great Schools Partnership. More than three hundred Vermont students, community members and educators contributed to the final version.

‍

Learner Agency Is Not Visible in a Final Draft

Vermont names attributes that only appear across time: agency, well-being, and how a student responds when something does not work. On Wakelet’s Education Pro plan students retain their portfolios after graduation, and collections take documents, images, video and PDFs together.

‍

Read more